Introduction: SIP – A Smart Investment Choice?
Systematic Investment Plans (SIPs) have gained immense popularity in India over the last decade. They are marketed as the easiest and smartest way to invest in mutual funds—especially for salaried individuals or beginners with limited market knowledge. SIPs allow investors to put a fixed amount regularly (monthly or quarterly) in mutual fund schemes, helping them inculcate a disciplined habit of investing.
But here’s the real question:
Can SIP investments give negative returns?
While many believe SIPs always generate profits in the long run, the truth is a bit more nuanced. This blog will dive deep into whether SIPs can go into the red, the reasons behind such negative returns, and how investors can protect themselves.
What Is a SIP (Systematic Investment Plan)?
Before we delve into the risks, let’s understand how a SIP works.
A SIP is a method of investing a fixed sum in a mutual fund at regular intervals, regardless of market conditions. You buy more units when prices are low and fewer when prices are high—this is called Rupee Cost Averaging. Over time, this strategy is believed to smooth out volatility and potentially maximize returns.
Key Benefits of SIPs:
- Affordable investment starting at ₹100
- Disciplined wealth creation
- Power of compounding
- Rupee cost averaging during market volatility
- Suitable for long-term financial goals
The Myth: SIPs Always Generate Positive Returns
There is a widespread belief that SIPs are fail-proof. Many believe that investing through SIPs will always give positive returns if held for the long term.
While this belief is largely true when considering a 10–15-year horizon, it is not guaranteed, especially in the short to medium term (3–5 years).
Yes, SIPs Can Give Negative Returns – But Why?
Let’s clarify it with an example.
Suppose you started a SIP in a high-risk equity fund in 2020, just before the pandemic hit and the markets crashed. For the next few months, your investments might show negative returns. Even after the market recovers, if the chosen fund underperforms or the economy remains unstable, you may not make any profits—or worse, face losses.
Real Scenarios Where SIPs May Give Negative Returns
1. Short Investment Duration
SIPs are not ideal for short-term investing in equity funds. If you invest for just 1–2 years, you might not give the fund enough time to recover from market corrections. Historical data shows that short-duration SIPs in equity funds have sometimes delivered negative or zero returns.
2. Bear Market or Recession Phase
During extended bear markets or economic downturns (like the 2008 global crisis or 2020 COVID crash), mutual fund NAVs fall. If your SIP continues during these times, your average investment cost may not be low enough to recover once markets stabilize.
3. Poor Fund Selection
All mutual funds are not equal. If you invest in a poorly managed fund with high expense ratios, bad portfolio allocation, or one that’s not aligned with your goals, it can erode your returns—even via SIP.
4. Wrong Asset Class
SIPs are often done in equity mutual funds, but if you unknowingly invest in thematic or sectoral funds without understanding risks, your SIP could result in negative returns.
For example, a SIP in a real estate or pharma sector fund might underperform when the sector faces regulatory challenges or demand slumps.
5. Global Events and Black Swan Crises
War, inflation spikes, oil price shocks, or geopolitical tensions can cause global market panic. SIP returns may temporarily fall into the negative during such unforeseen situations.
Historical Evidence: When SIPs Gave Negative Returns
Let’s examine real numbers.
| Year of SIP Start | Investment Duration | Fund Type | Return Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2007 | 2 Years | Equity Large Cap | Negative (~-10%) |
| 2010 | 3 Years | Small Cap | Negative (~-5%) |
| 2015 | 5 Years | Sector Fund (Infra) | Negative (~-8%) |
| 2018 | 3 Years | Mid Cap | Slightly Negative or Flat |
Note: Returns vary based on fund, timing, and overall market.
How to Minimize the Risk of Negative SIP Returns
1. Invest for the Long Term (7+ years)
SIPs work best when you allow them to ride through market cycles. The longer you stay invested, the greater the power of compounding and rupee cost averaging.
SIPs in top-performing equity funds held for over 10 years have historically delivered 12–15% CAGR returns.
2. Choose the Right Fund Category
Depending on your risk appetite:
- Low risk: Large-cap or Balanced Advantage Funds
- Medium risk: Flexi-cap or Hybrid funds
- High risk: Small-cap or Sectoral Funds (only if you understand the volatility)
3. Diversify Your SIP Portfolio
Don’t put all your SIP money in one fund. Mix of:
- Equity SIP (for growth)
- Debt SIP (for stability)
- ELSS SIP (for tax saving)
4. Avoid Timing the Market
Don’t stop or pause your SIP during market crashes. In fact, these are the best times to accumulate more units at lower prices.
5. Review and Rebalance Annually
At least once a year, assess the performance of your SIPs. Exit consistently underperforming funds and reinvest in better alternatives.
SIP Returns in Different Mutual Fund Types
| Mutual Fund Type | Ideal SIP Duration | Average Return Range | Risk Level |
|---|---|---|---|
| Large Cap Fund | 7–10 years | 10–12% | Moderate |
| Flexi Cap Fund | 7–10 years | 11–14% | Moderate to High |
| Small Cap Fund | 10+ years | 14–18% | High |
| Hybrid Funds | 5–7 years | 8–10% | Low to Moderate |
| Debt Funds | 3–5 years | 6–8% | Low |
Should You Stop SIPs if You See Negative Returns?
Absolutely not.
SIP returns being negative in the short term is not a failure of the investment itself—it’s simply a market cycle. In fact, continuing your SIPs during a downturn helps in lowering the average cost and sets you up for stronger gains when the market recovers.
“Corrections are temporary. Growth is permanent.”
SIPs vs Lump Sum: Which is Safer?
Let’s compare both options from the risk of negative returns.
| Factor | SIP | Lump Sum |
|---|---|---|
| Volatility impact | Lower (averaging out cost) | Higher |
| Ideal in market highs | Yes | No |
| Ideal in market crashes | Yes | Yes, but timing needed |
| Discipline | High | Low |
| Risk of negative return | Medium | High (if mistimed) |
Clearly, SIPs offer a better risk-adjusted route to investing for average investors.
Taxation Angle – Even Negative SIPs Can Have Tax Impact
Even if your SIP is giving negative returns temporarily, remember:
- Capital gains tax is applicable on redemptions.
- SIP units have different holding periods. Gains on units held <1 year attract 15% STCG; above 1 year, 10% LTCG after ₹1 lakh exemption.
So avoid exiting SIPs prematurely just because of temporary red or flat returns. Let compounding do its job.
SIP Is Not a Magic Bullet—It Needs Planning
Most people treat SIP as a “set it and forget it” tool. But to avoid disappointment:
- Start early
- Invest consistently
- Pick the right funds
- Stay invested long term
- Monitor performance annually
Real Investor Stories: When SIPs Paid Off After Negatives
Example 1: Rakesh, 28, Delhi – Midcap SIP
Started in 2017. By 2020 (Covid crash), SIP value was down 12%. He continued investing. By 2023, he saw 22% CAGR overall!
Example 2: Meena, 35, Bangalore – ELSS SIP
Started in 2015. 3-year performance was poor (-3%). But by 2022, she gained 14% CAGR and tax benefits worth ₹1.5 lakh.
FAQs – Can SIP Give Negative Returns?
Q1: How often do SIPs give negative returns?
A: Very rarely in long-term (7–10 year) investments, but quite possible in short-term (1–3 years), especially in equity markets.
Q2: Is SIP safe for beginners?
A: Yes, but invest in diversified or large-cap funds and be patient.
Q3: Can I lose all my money in SIP?
A: Unless the fund crashes completely (which is extremely rare for regulated funds), complete loss is unlikely.
Q4: Should I continue SIP during market downturn?
A: Yes. That’s when SIP works best through rupee cost averaging.
Q5: Can I change the SIP amount?
A: Yes. Most platforms allow step-up SIPs or modifying the amount.
Conclusion: SIPs Can Give Negative Returns—But That’s Not the End
So, to answer the big question:
Yes, SIP investments can give negative returns—especially in the short term or during market downturns.
But they remain one of the safest and most effective long-term investment tools, especially for salaried individuals and risk-conscious investors. The key is to stay consistent, avoid panic, diversify, and review periodically.
Invest wisely, and let time and compounding reward your patience.
If you found this post useful, don’t forget to share it and drop your questions in the comment box below. Happy investing!